Is my music video good?

[TVavengedSevenfold]

I made a music video for this song God Hates Us, and my goal was to make the music video as much as possible relating to the lyrics and moral, but I fear in doing so I may have lost the tempo. This is what I have done.

Avenged Sevenfold - God Hates Us Music Video - YouTube

There is another music not made by me, which is perhaps tempo for the song but has really no correlation to the lyrics and it is this one.

God Hates Us-Avenged Sevenfold{MUSIC VIDEO} - YouTube

Which music video is overall the best?

Thank you for your time.

[Midnight Blue]

Neither are music videos. They are both videos made from clips of Hollywood movies put together and a death metal music track added.

[TVavengedSevenfold]

Neither are music videos. They are both videos made from clips of Hollywood movies put together and a death metal music track added.

Yes I know, but there is no official music video so I made one, and was just asking for some feedback for my editing.