Second Attempt at Breaking my Wall.

[JumPROper]

I've tried this before and the second attempt is definitely better, but I still want to know how to improve it.

[Midnight Blue]

I've never don't this sort of thing but what I've observed is:
1. The masking on the hand and arm still shows a black area around it.
2. The damage on the wall and the reflection don't match
3. The damage on the wall is very 2 dimensional and doesn't look real
4. There should be an impression where the fist hit the wall or at least lumps of plaster fall off.
5. You cast a shadow on the wall but this is not shown in the reflection.

Apart from that it looked OK.

[JumPROper]

Thanks for the feedback! Very helpful