Given the rules of this forum, can we all please agree on what we mean by "Constructive Criticism"
Mark W, it appears from your other postings that you believe it means no negative comments or only positive comments, yes?
Please correct me if I'm wrong.
I believe it means criticism of any kind, positive or negative but backed up by some reasoning or advice.
In other words:
"Your film sucks" - is just negative criticism
"Your film sucks because the camera work was shakey, the sound unintelligible" - is constructive criticism.
So I can totally understand people only wanting to receive constructive criticism, given my understanding.
And it does, after all, in the header for this forum state "By posting your work here you agree to have your work subject to constructive critism." so you can't really blame people for asking for it