In my opinion the camera movements fit perfectly with the genre - they're trying to get across a cramped and hostile environment and smooth crisp lines just wouldn't fit the mustard. People said the same thing about Arrested Development, but again I personally thought it perfectly suited the anarchy of the Blueth family. It just adds to the atmosphere as much as the smooth shots of a steadicam did for The Shining.
Personally I think it adds an extra level of intensity. You feel more a part of the events rather than just a spectator (if you really were on the Battestar galatica you'd be experiencing constant movement, people in your face and sudden changes - buy simulating this through the camera movements, you add that level if intamacy you wouldn't otherwise get). When you're running full pelt for the train or bus, do you see the world glide pass and focus on one thing, or do you have a million and one things get in your way? Your head lolls one way and another.
So, in summary, I strongly disagree. |