Ok. My critique.
Hope. Really liked the look and feel of this. Lovely dreamy look, nice flowing shots, good music too. Overall a really good video. Downsides? Didn't care for the orangy look at the end or the snow effect near the beginning. Have much respect because it was actually made for the comp instead of mine where I just used my families antics to blag my way in.
Manger Scene As a technical exercise it came out pretty well. The animated animals were pretty good, and apart from the fade out on Mary's shawl and lack of overall 'story', a good effort.
CSIBThis took me by surprise. Two stars in the making? Maybe not, but entertaining nevertheless. A kind of Police Squad feel here and there that worked pretty well. I thought the lighting was a little harsh in the house and there was a continuity flaw with the guy in the door which I'm still wondering was intentional. The Bunny ears made me spit my tea out, so ten out of ten for that. I did think the opening dragged a little though. Would love to see the outtake reel, particularly the T.O.S.S.E.R. lines!
Luke - voting arrangments seem a little haphazard, since there isn't a form like 1,2,3,4 in order of preference. I think we need that.
|